Helping California Families With Their Estate Needs
Estate Planning
We create and update estate plans that protect our clients’ futures.
Estate Administration
We guide families through the administration of trusts and other assets.
welcome to dayton law firm
Build A Plan That
Works For You
Anyone with assets can benefit from an estate plan. We offer options for people from all walks of life. Estate planning can save your loved ones from making difficult decisions after you pass away or if you become unable to make your own decisions. It can also ensure that your wishes for both your assets and your care will be met.
At The Dayton Law Firm, P.C., our team of San Jose estate planning attorneys is compassionate to families and individuals. We aim to help answer questions about your long-term planning options. We help with a variety of estate needs, including:
- Wills and trusts
- Retirement planning
- Probate
- Asset protection
- Trust administration
Why Choose Us?
We focus on our clients. While some firms seek the highest-value cases with disregard for the clients’ needs, we focus solely on what techniques are going to help you most.
Competitive Pricing
We strive to keep our hourly and flat fees accessible to as many families as possible.
Experience
We use our knowledge from planning and administering estates to achieve efficient legal solutions with a process proven to work.
Personalized Legal Work
By blending industry standards with custom in-house templates, we can advise and customize your plan to include your wishes to make sure it works how you want.
Free Consultations
We offer initial consultations at no charge so we can evaluate your legal needs before you ever receive a bill. Please call us at 408-758-5750 or email us to schedule an appointment.
Our firm is located in San Jose and serves the entire Bay Area. We also serve clients throughout California.
latest articles
Our Recent Blogs
Few things are harder than opening a parent’s will and finding something that makes no sense. A caregiver who appeared in the last year of your mother’s life now inherits the house, or your sibling who handled Dad’s finances is suddenly the sole beneficiary. When the estate includes a Santa Clara County home, the difference between one version of a will and another can easily run into seven figures.
California does give family members and beneficiaries a way to challenge a will they believe is invalid. But the law is narrow. You cannot contest a will simply because it feels unfair, and the deadlines are short and unforgiving. This guide explains who can bring a California will contest, the legal grounds courts recognize, how the process works, and the deadlines that control everything.
Important: This article provides general information about California law. It is not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Will contests turn on specific facts and strict deadlines. If you believe a will is invalid, speak with a licensed California attorney about your situation as soon as possible.
Who Can Contest a Will in California?
Only an “interested person” can bring a will contest, a term defined in Probate Code Section 48. In practical terms, that usually means someone who would receive more if the will were thrown out. Common examples include:
- Children or other heirs who would inherit under California’s intestate succession rules if no valid will existed
- Beneficiaries named in an earlier will who were cut out or reduced by a later one
- Beneficiaries whose share was changed by a codicil they believe is invalid
A neighbor who was promised a painting but never appeared in any will generally lacks standing. So does an heir who would receive the same amount no matter which document controls.
Grounds to Contest a Will in California
California’s Probate Code lists the recognized grounds directly. Under Section 8252, the person defending the will must prove it was properly executed, while the person challenging it carries the burden of proving lack of testamentary intent or capacity, undue influence, fraud, duress, mistake, or revocation. Here is what those grounds look like in real disputes.
Lack of Testamentary Capacity
The bar for making a valid will is lower than most people expect. Under Probate Code Section 6100.5, a person lacks capacity if, at the moment of signing, they could not understand what making a will means, could not recall the nature of their property, or could not remember and understand their relationships with close family and others affected by the will. A will can also fail if a mental health disorder caused delusions or hallucinations that led the person to leave property in a way they otherwise would not have.
A dementia diagnosis alone does not automatically invalidate a will. Capacity is measured at the time of signing, and people with cognitive decline can have lucid periods. Strong capacity cases usually rely on medical records, physician testimony, and witnesses who observed the person’s condition around the date the will was signed.
Undue Influence
Undue influence is the most common ground in California will disputes, and often the most emotionally charged. California borrows its definition from the elder abuse statutes: undue influence is excessive persuasion that overcomes a person’s free will and produces an unfair result. Courts look at factors such as the vulnerability of the person making the will, the influencer’s position of authority or trust, the tactics used (isolation, controlling access to family, controlling finances), and whether the outcome was inequitable.
Two presumptions can shift the burden onto the person who benefited:
- The common-law presumption. If the challenger shows the beneficiary had a confidential relationship with the decedent, actively participated in getting the will prepared or signed, and received an undue benefit, the beneficiary must then prove the absence of undue influence.
- The statutory presumption. Probate Code Section 21380 presumes a gift is the product of fraud or undue influence when it goes to the person who drafted the will, a fiduciary who transcribed it, or a care custodian of a dependent adult if the will was signed during the caregiving period or within 90 days before or after. The beneficiary can overcome this only with clear and convincing evidence, and a gift to the drafter is conclusively presumed invalid.
These presumptions matter enormously in the Bay Area, where aging parents often rely on paid caregivers or a single adult child who lives nearby.
Fraud
Fraud comes in two main forms. Fraud in the execution happens when someone signs a will believing it is a different document. Fraud in the inducement happens when someone lies to the testator to change their plans, such as falsely claiming a child has been stealing from them. Forgery, where the decedent never signed the document at all, is also a basis for challenge.
Improper Execution
A formal California will must be in writing, signed by the testator, and witnessed by two people who were present at the same time and understood the document was the testator’s will (Probate Code Section 6110). A handwritten (holographic) will can be valid without witnesses, but its signature and material provisions must be in the testator’s own handwriting. If a witness also receives a gift under the will, the law presumes the gift was obtained through duress, menace, fraud, or undue influence unless that witness proves otherwise.
That said, courts can still admit a technically flawed will if there is clear and convincing evidence the testator intended it to be their will, so execution defects are not automatic wins.
Duress, Mistake, and Revocation
Duress involves threats or coercion. Mistake covers narrow situations where the document does not reflect what the testator intended to sign. Revocation arises when a later will or a physical act, such as intentionally destroying the original, canceled the will being offered for probate.
What Is Not a Valid Reason to Contest
California protects a person’s right to leave property however they choose. Unequal gifts, disinheriting a child, or leaving everything to a new spouse are not grounds for a contest on their own. We explain the rules around this in our article on disinheriting family in California.
Some situations that feel like will contests are actually separate claims. A spouse or child who was accidentally left out because the will predates the marriage or the child’s birth may have an omitted spouse or omitted child claim. These follow different rules, and an attorney can tell you which path fits your facts.
California Will Contest Deadlines
Timing controls whether you get to argue your case at all. There are two windows.
Before the Will Is Admitted to Probate
When someone files a petition to probate a will, notice of the hearing is published in a local newspaper and mailed to heirs and beneficiaries. An interested person can file a written objection before the court admits the will. Under Section 8250, a summons is then issued, and the other parties have 30 days after service to respond. Objecting at this stage is generally the strongest position because it stops the will from being admitted while the dispute is resolved.
The 120-Day Window After Admission
If the will has already been admitted, Probate Code Section 8270 gives interested persons 120 days from the date of admission to petition the court to revoke probate. The clock runs from admission, not from the date of death and not from when you first saw the will.
There are important limits. Anyone who was already a party to a will contest, or who had actual notice of one in time to join it, generally cannot file a separate petition. The main exception protects people who were minors or legally incompetent without a guardian or conservator when the will was admitted. They may petition any time before the court orders final distribution.
If the Estate Plan Uses a Trust
Many Bay Area estates pass through a living trust with a pour-over will. Trust contests follow a separate deadline under Probate Code Section 16061.8, generally 120 days after the trustee serves the required notice, or 60 days after a copy of the trust is delivered on request, whichever is later. If you have received a trustee’s notice, treat that date as urgent.
In our experience, missed deadlines and missed notice requirements are among the most common mistakes people make when they try to handle probate matters on their own. A strong contest filed on day 121 is usually no contest at all.
How a Will Contest Works, Step by Step
Every case is different, but most California will contests follow a similar path.
- Get the documents. The person holding an original will must deliver it to the court clerk within 30 days of learning of the death. Once a probate case is open, the petition, the will, and later filings are part of the court record. Obtain copies of any earlier wills as well.
- Evaluate standing, grounds, and risk. An attorney will assess whether you are an interested person, which grounds the facts support, and what you stand to gain. If the will contains a no-contest clause, California enforces it only in limited situations, including a direct contest brought without probable cause. Our guide to no-contest clauses in California trusts and wills explains how this works.
- File the objection or petition to revoke. The filing must state the written grounds of opposition, and the summons must be served on the personal representative and the heirs and beneficiaries.
- Discovery. Both sides gather evidence: medical records, the drafting attorney’s file and testimony, witness depositions, bank records, and communications that show who arranged the will and why.
- Mediation and settlement. Most will contests resolve before trial. Litigation is expensive, and a negotiated outcome often preserves more of the estate for everyone.
- Hearing or trial. California will contests are decided by a judge, not a jury. In Santa Clara County, the local probate rules provide that contested matters requiring three hours or less may be heard by the Probate Division, while longer hearings and trials go to the Civil Division’s master trial calendar, with the Probate Division handling issues up to trial. Probate matters are heard at the Downtown Superior Courthouse at 191 North First Street in San Jose.
If the court invalidates the will, the estate passes under the most recent valid earlier will or, if there is none, under intestate succession.
Probate’s Structure Can Help You
Nearly everything written about estate planning tells people to avoid probate. As Martin H. Bayer, an attorney with our firm, points out, the rigid, court-supervised nature of probate is sometimes an advantage. Every step is on the record. Required notices must go to heirs and beneficiaries. Court staff attorneys review filings before a judge rules. Compare that to a family trust where one sibling serves as trustee and the other two receive little information. In that setting, problems can go unnoticed far longer.
For a potential contestant, that structure means you are more likely to receive notice, there is a court file to review, and a judge oversees the outcome. It also means the process runs on fixed timelines. Some counties, including San Benito and Santa Cruz, enforce local probate deadlines strictly, while Santa Clara County has historically been more flexible on certain administrative filings. Do not mistake that flexibility for leniency on contest deadlines. The 120-day window in Section 8270 is set by statute, not local practice.
It is also worth being realistic about cost. Litigation has a price, and not every concern justifies a lawsuit. A candid attorney will help you weigh what is at stake, such as your share of assets subject to probate or an interest in the family home, against the time, expense, and family strain a contest involves.
Talk to a San Jose Will Contest Attorney Before the Deadline Passes
If you suspect a loved one’s will was the product of undue influence, fraud, or diminished capacity, the most important step is getting timely advice. Evidence fades, witnesses become harder to reach, and the 120-day clock does not pause while families sort out their feelings.
The Dayton Law Firm, P.C. serves families in San Jose, Santa Clara County, and throughout the Bay Area, including San Mateo, Alameda, and San Benito counties. Learn more about our probate practice or contact us to schedule a consultation.
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Every situation is different, and the law may change. Please consult a qualified California attorney about your specific circumstances before taking action.
When someone in Santa Clara County dies without a will, the family’s questions usually come fast. Who gets the house? Does the surviving spouse inherit everything? What about the kids from a first marriage, or the brother nobody has spoken to in years?
California answers those questions with a fixed set of rules called intestate succession, found in Probate Code sections 6400 through 6414.
What “Intestate” Means Under California Law
A person dies “intestate” when they leave no valid will, or when their will does not dispose of all of their property. Under Probate Code section 6400, anything not effectively given away by a will passes to the decedent’s heirs as the law prescribes.
An “heir at law” in California is anyone, including a surviving spouse, who is entitled to inherit under these rules. Being an heir has nothing to do with closeness or who provided care in the final years. It is determined entirely by legal relationship and the order set out in the statute.
It also matters what intestacy does not reach. Assets held in a living trust, property owned in joint tenancy, and accounts with a named beneficiary (life insurance, IRAs, 401(k)s, payable-on-death accounts) pass according to their own terms. Intestate succession only governs the property that was left in the decedent’s own name with no other instructions. Our guide to what assets are subject to probate in California walks through those categories in more detail.
Step One: Separate Community Property From Separate Property
For a married decedent, the first question is not who the relatives are. It is what kind of property is in the estate. California is a community property state, and Probate Code section 6401 treats the two types very differently.
Community property is generally anything acquired during the marriage by either spouse’s earnings or efforts. The surviving spouse already owns half of it. Under section 6401(a), the decedent’s half also goes to the surviving spouse. In practical terms, the surviving spouse ends up with 100 percent of the community property, no matter how many children or other relatives survive. Quasi-community property (property acquired while living in another state that would have been community property here) follows the same rule.
Separate property is property owned before the marriage, or received during the marriage by gift or inheritance, and kept separate. This is where other relatives can share with the spouse.
Registered domestic partners are treated the same as spouses for inheritance purposes under Family Code section 297.5. It is worth noting that this applies only to officially registered domestic partners. California does not recognize the concept of a “common-law” marriage.
When community property is passing to a surviving spouse, a full probate is often unnecessary. A spousal property petition can confirm the transfer through a simpler court process. Martin H. Bayer, the firm’s probate attorney, sees a recurring version of this problem with Bay Area homes: a married couple owns a house, one spouse dies, and nobody does anything with the title. Years later the second spouse dies, and the family discovers they may be facing two estates instead of one. A spousal property petition can often be used to confirm that the first spouse’s interest passed to the survivor, so that only the second estate needs to be probated.
The Surviving Spouse’s Share of Separate Property
For separate property, section 6401(c) gives the surviving spouse a share that depends on who else survives:
| Who else survives the decedent | Spouse’s share of separate property |
|---|---|
| No children, grandchildren, parents, siblings, or nieces and nephews | All of it |
| One child (or the descendants of one deceased child) | One-half |
| No descendants, but a parent, or siblings or their descendants | One-half |
| Two or more children, or one child plus descendants of a deceased child | One-third |
Here is how that plays out. Suppose a San Jose woman dies without a will, survived by her husband and two adult children. The family home was bought during the marriage with both spouses’ salaries, so it is community property and goes entirely to her husband. She also had a brokerage account she inherited from her mother and never commingled. That account is separate property, so her husband takes one-third and each child takes one-third.
The distinction between the two types of property is not always clean. Refinances, remodels paid for with community funds, and accounts that mixed inherited money with paychecks can all blur the lines, and characterization disputes are among the most common sources of conflict in intestate estates.
When There Is No Spouse: The Order of Inheritance
Whatever does not go to a surviving spouse (or the entire estate, if there is no spouse) passes under Probate Code section 6402. Each level inherits only if no one survives at the level above it:
- Issue. Children, and the descendants of any child who died first.
- Parents. Split equally if both are living.
- Issue of parents. Brothers and sisters, and the children or grandchildren of siblings who died first.
- Grandparents or their issue. Grandparents, then aunts, uncles, and cousins.
- Issue of a predeceased spouse. For example, stepchildren who were the children of a spouse who died before the decedent.
- Next of kin. The nearest relatives by degree, with a preference for those claiming through the closest common ancestor.
- Parents of a predeceased spouse or their issue. Former in-laws and their descendants.
Only if this entire chain comes up empty does the estate pass to the State of California under section 6404, a result called escheat. It is rare, but it does happen with decedents who were truly alone.
How Shares Pass to Grandchildren, Nieces, and Nephews
When some members of a generation have died, California uses the method in Probate Code section 240 to divide shares. The estate is split at the first generation that has a living member, and the share of anyone in that generation who died is divided among their descendants.
Say a widower dies with three children, but one daughter died years earlier and left two children of her own. The estate is divided into three shares. Each surviving child takes one-third, and the two grandchildren split their mother’s third, so each receives one-sixth.
If all three children had died first, the division would start at the grandchild generation instead, and every grandchild would take an equal share regardless of which parent they came through.
Rules Families Often Miss
The remaining sections of the intestacy chapter fill in details that come up more often than people expect:
- The 120-hour survival rule (section 6403): An heir who does not survive the decedent by at least 120 hours is treated as having died first. This matters in accidents and in families where two relatives die within days of each other. The rule does not apply if it would cause the estate to escheat to the state.
- Property from a predeceased spouse (section 6402.5): If the decedent left no spouse and no descendants, but had a spouse who died within 15 years (for real property) or 5 years (for certain personal property), the portion of the estate that came from that earlier spouse may go to the earlier spouse’s family instead. This rule regularly surprises siblings who assumed they would inherit everything.
- Half-blood relatives (section 6406): Half-siblings inherit the same share as full siblings.
- Children born after death (section 6407): A relative conceived before the decedent died but born afterward inherits as if born during the decedent’s lifetime.
- Lifetime gifts and debts (sections 6409 and 6410): A gift made during life counts as an advance on an heir’s inheritance only if it was documented in writing as an advancement. A debt an heir owed the decedent is charged against that heir’s share.
- Citizenship (section 6411): An heir is not disqualified for not being a U.S. citizen. For families with relatives abroad, this is worth knowing, though locating and notifying heirs overseas adds real time to the case.
- Double relationships (section 6413): Someone related through two lines of the family takes only one share.
- Stepchildren and foster children: They do not inherit by default. Under Probate Code section 6454, a stepchild or foster child can inherit only if the relationship began when the child was a minor, lasted throughout both lives, and there is clear and convincing evidence the adult would have adopted the child but for a legal barrier. Legally adopted children inherit exactly like biological children.
Many of these rules are very nuanced and we have not covered every variation here. You should consult with a qualified attorney if you think any of these may apply to your situation.
Who Manages the Estate When There Is No Will?
With no will, there is no named executor. The court appoints an administrator, following a priority list that starts with the surviving spouse or domestic partner, then children, then other relatives. Most of the time the administrator is a family member. The court will usually require the administrator to post a bond unless the heirs waive it.
The administrator is entitled to statutory compensation, and many families are surprised to learn it is calculated on exactly the same percentage schedule as the attorney’s statutory fee. As Martin Bayer puts it, the personal representative and the attorney are each entitled to the same calculation under the Probate Code, which effectively doubles the ordinary fee schedule.
If there is no one willing or able to administer the estate or if the parties cannot agree to an administrator, the court may appoint a professional fiduciary as the administrator instead.
Does Every Intestate Estate Need a Full Probate?
Not necessarily. Bayer’s first question at an initial consultation is whether probate is really required at all. For deaths on or after April 1, 2025, heirs can collect personal property worth up to $208,850 with a small estate affidavit under Probate Code section 13100, without going to court. A separate petition under section 13151 can transfer a decedent’s primary residence worth up to $750,000.
In Santa Clara County, though, the primary residence limit rules out most homes, so a house left without a will or trust usually means formal probate, filed at the Downtown Superior Court at 191 North First Street in San Jose. Our article on what happens to a house during probate covers what families can expect while the case is pending.
Probate Is Not Always the Villain
Probate has a reputation as something to avoid at all costs. Bayer takes a more nuanced view. Probate is rigid and court-supervised, and that supervision is precisely what protects heirs. Court staff attorneys review the filings, and the judge confirms that each heir receives what the law says they are entitled to. Compare that to a trust with three children where one sibling serves as trustee and no court is watching. For an intestate family where relationships are strained, or where some heirs are distant relatives who barely know each other, the structure of probate can prevent the kind of self-dealing that would otherwise be too expensive to pursue.
If minor children are among the heirs, their shares cannot simply be handed over. Our article on protecting minor children’s inheritances in California explains the options.
Talk to a San Jose Probate Attorney
Intestate succession looks mechanical on paper, but the answers depend on questions that are rarely simple: whether property is community or separate, who all the heirs are, and whether a shortcut procedure applies. The Dayton Law Firm, P.C. represents administrators and heirs in probate matters in the San Francisco Bay Area, Silicon Valley, and throughout California. If a loved one has died without a will, contact our office or call 408-437-7570 to schedule a free consultation about the estate and your rights as an heir.
When a Santa Clara County family opens a probate case, one of the first things the court does is appoint someone to run the estate. That person is called the Personal Representative, and understanding this role, who qualifies, what they’re required to do, and what happens if they get it wrong, is often the first real question families ask when a loved one passes away owning property in San Jose or elsewhere in the Bay Area.
Note: The content in this article is to be considered an overview only, and does not constitute legal advice. Every situation is different, and the law may change. Please consult a qualified California attorney about your specific circumstances before taking action.
Personal Representative: The Umbrella Term
“Personal Representative” is the term California law uses to describe whoever is legally authorized to administer a decedent’s estate through the probate court. It covers two distinct roles that people often use interchangeably but that actually depend on how the decedent died.
Executor: Named in a Will
An executor is the person the decedent specifically named in their will to handle the estate. If someone in San Jose signs a will and names their eldest daughter as executor, that daughter has first right to serve, assuming she’s willing and legally qualified. The probate court still has to formally appoint her and issue what are called letters testamentary, but the decedent already made the choice.
Administrator: No Will, or No Named Executor
An administrator steps in when there’s no will (intestate succession), when the will fails to name an executor, or when the named executor can’t or won’t serve. In these cases, California Probate Code section 8461 sets out a priority order for who the court will appoint, generally starting with the surviving spouse or domestic partner, then children, then other relatives in descending order, with the public administrator as a last resort. Once appointed, this person receives letters of administration rather than letters testamentary, but their authority and responsibilities are functionally the same as an executor’s.
In practice, most San Jose families have someone willing to serve. It’s rare for a probate matter to move forward without a person stepping into this role, and it’s usually a family member working through that priority order rather than an outside professional. Private professional fiduciaries exist for situations where no suitable family member is available, though many attorneys who focus on family estates see less of this than the volume of California probate filings might suggest.
How Someone Becomes a Personal Representative
Appointment isn’t automatic, even for a named executor. The proposed Personal Representative must file a petition with the probate court, which in Santa Clara County means Santa Clara County Superior Court, along with the original will if one exists. The court schedules a hearing, requires notice to heirs and beneficiaries, and only then issues letters authorizing the person to act.
This is also the point where an initial and important question gets asked: is a full probate even required? Depending on the size and composition of the estate, a full court-supervised case might not be necessary. Smaller estates, or those involving only specific assets like a bank account under a statutory dollar threshold, may qualify for a simplified petition instead. The distinction between how personal property and real property are treated under these simplified procedures matters quite a bit, and it’s worth confirming with an attorney before assuming a full probate is unavoidable.
Core Duties of the Personal Representative
Once appointed, a personal representative takes on fiduciary duties to the estate’s heirs, beneficiaries, and creditors. The core responsibilities include:
Marshaling Assets and filing an Inventory & Appraisal
California Probate Code §8800 requires the Personal Representative to file an inventory and appraisal of estate assets within 4 months after Letters are issued. Strict enforcement of this deadline varies by county. Some Bay Area counties are fairly relaxed about it in practice, while others, including San Benito and Santa Cruz, actively enforce it and will schedule an order to show cause hearing if it’s filed late. In all cases, the Personal Representative should not assume local flexibility applies and should make every effort to adhere to this requirement or explain to the Court why the requirement cannot be met.
Notice to Creditors and the Public
The Personal Representative must publish notice of the probate proceeding in a newspaper of general circulation and file proof that the publication happened. Before the hearing, they must also give notice to everyone entitled to notice under the will or intestacy rules. After they are appointed, they must also give direct notice to known creditors and to anyone entitled to notice under the will or intestacy rules. This is important because it starts a timer that limits a creditor’s claim filing deadline.
Managing and Protecting Estate Assets
This includes securing property, maintaining insurance, managing bank accounts, and generally acting as a prudent steward of everything in the estate until distribution.
Paying Valid Debts and Taxes
Before beneficiaries receive anything, the estate’s legitimate debts, taxes, and administration expenses have to be resolved.
Final Distribution
Once the court approves a final accounting, the Personal Representative distributes the remaining assets according to the will or California’s intestate succession rules.
Bond Requirements
California Probate Code section 8480 generally requires every appointed personal representative to post a bond before letters are issued. The bond protects beneficiaries and creditors against mismanagement or misconduct by the person running the estate.
A bond can be waived under Probate Code section 8481 if the will specifically waives the requirement, or if all beneficiaries agree in writing to waive it. Even then, the court retains discretion to require a bond anyway if there’s good cause, for example, if the proposed personal representative lives outside California. When a will affirmatively requires a bond, that requirement generally can’t be waived by the beneficiaries.
Compensation for Personal Representatives
California sets personal representative compensation by statute rather than by private agreement. Under Probate Code section 10800, the personal representative is entitled to a percentage-based fee calculated on the value of the estate they account for: 4 percent of the first $100,000, 3 percent of the next $100,000, 2 percent of the next $800,000, tapering down from there on larger estates.
What surprises a lot of people, including some who have handled the process before, is that the estate’s attorney is entitled to that exact same fee schedule under Probate Code section 10810. So, a family member serving as personal representative and the probate attorney they hire can each collect the same statutory percentage, meaning total ordinary fees on a probate estate are effectively double the single schedule. Many family members who are also beneficiaries choose to waive their own statutory fee. A key consideration is that the fee is taxable income to them while an inheritance generally isn’t.
Liability and Removal
Because the role carries fiduciary duties, a Personal Representative who breaches those duties, through self-dealing, mismanagement, missed deadlines, or simple negligence, can be held personally liable to the estate. The court can surcharge a personal representative for losses caused by a breach, and in serious cases, remove them from the role entirely.
This is a common reason families sometimes assume probate is something to avoid at all costs, but that’s not always the right conclusion. Probate is a rigid, court-supervised process precisely because of these fiduciary obligations. Every accounting gets reviewed by court staff, and every distribution is subject to judicial oversight. Compare that to a trust administered by a single family member trustee with far less built-in scrutiny. For families concerned about fairness among heirs, that level of court oversight is sometimes a genuine advantage rather than a burden.
Common Mistakes When Personal Representatives Go It Alone
Personal representatives who handle a California probate without an attorney, appearing “pro per,” run into predictable trouble. The most common missteps include missing filing deadlines, failing to publish notice properly, failing to file proof of that publication, missing required affidavits, and failing to give timely and complete notice of hearing dates to everyone entitled to receive it. Any one of these errors can delay a case by months or expose the personal representative to personal liability.
Serving as Personal Representative in Santa Clara County
If you’ve been named executor in a will or you’re next in line to serve as administrator for a family member’s estate in San Jose or elsewhere in Santa Clara County, understanding these obligations before you accept the role matters. The Dayton Law Firm, P.C. guides personal representatives through every stage of California probate administration, from the initial petition through final distribution, so you can meet your fiduciary duties with confidence and avoid the mistakes that create liability. Contact our office to schedule a consultation and discuss your specific situation.